Quest 3 - Pi Types

We will try to formulate and prove the statement

Problem statement

The sum of two even naturals is even.

Part 0 - Defining Addition

To do so we must define + on the naturals. Addition takes in two naturals and spits out a natural, so it should have type .

_+_ :     
n + m = ?

Try coming up with a sensible definition. It may not look the same as ours.

Hint

n + 0 should be n and n + (m + 1) should be (n + m) + 1.

Part 1 - The Statement

Now we can make the statement that a sum of even naturals is even in agda. Make sure it is of the form

Name : Statement
Name = ?

The statement should be of the form (x y : A) B where A represents the subset of even naturals and B expresses what it means for the “sum of x and y” to be even.

Hint

Given x y : Σ isEven we want to show that their sum (really the sum of their fist components) is even, so we should give isEven (x .fst + y .fst)

Tip

x .fst is another notation for fst x. This works for all sigma types.

There are three ways to interpret this:

Spoiler
  • For all even naturals x and y, their sum is even.

  • isEven (x .fst + y .fst) is a construction depending on two recipes x and y. Given two recipes x and y of Σ isEven, we break them down into their first components, apply the conversion _+_, and form a recipe for isEven of the result.

  • isEven (_ .fst + _ .fst) is a bundle over the categorical product Σ isEven × Σ isEven and SumOfEven is a section of the bundle. This means for every point (x , y) in Σ isEven × Σ isEven, it gives a point in the fiber isEven (x .fst + y .fst).

More generally given A : Type and B : A Type we can form the pi type (x : A) B x : Type (in other languages Π (x : ℕ), isEven n), with interpretations :

  • it is the proposition “for all x : A, we have B x”, and each term of the pi type is a collection of proofs ``bx : B x`, one for each x : A.

  • recipes of (x : A) B x are made by converting each x : A to some recipe of B x. Indeed the function type A B is the special case where the type B x is not dependent on x. Hence pi types are also known as dependent function types. Note that terms in the sigma type are pairs (a , b) whilst terms in the dependent function type are a collection of pairs (a , b) indexed by a : A

  • Given the bundle B : A Type, we have the total space Σ A B which is equipped with a projection fst : Σ A B A. A term of (x : A) B x is a section of this projection.

We are now in a position to prove the statement. Have fun!

Part 2 - Remarks

Important

Once you have proven the statement, check out our two ways of defining addition _+_ and _+'_ (in the solutions).

  • Use C-c C-n to check that they compute the same values on different examples.

  • Uncomment the code for Sum'OfEven in the solutions. It is just SumOfEven but with each + changed to +'.

  • Load the file. Does the proof still work?

Our proof SumOfEven relied on the explicit definition of _+_, which means if we wanted to use our proof on someone else’s definition of addition, it might not work anymore.

Important Question

But _+_ and _+'_ compute the same values. Are _+_ and _+'_ “the same”? What is “the same”?